3. Fiskfélagið (The Fish Company)
The Fish Company, known as “Fiskfélagið” in Icelandic, is a beloved gem within Reykjavik’s vibrant dining landscape. Nestled conveniently near Ingolfstorg square and just a leisurely stroll from the harbor, this restaurant has secured its place as a staple for both locals and visitors.
The menu offers a delightful journey across global cuisines, presenting each dish—be it a starter, main course, or dessert—with inspiration from different countries. Icelandic flavors certainly take center stage, but you’ll find enticing options influenced by culinary traditions from France, Italy, Greece, Japan, Argentina, and beyond— even including offerings from neighboring Greenland and the Faroe Islands!
This international theme extends to the wine list, brimming with diverse selections. The attentive staff is on hand to guide diners in selecting the perfect wine to complement their meal.
As for the ambiance, the Fish Company occupies a historic building dating back to 1884. The interior is a charming blend of large brick walls and exposed wooden beams, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere that’s perfect for a memorable night out.
With an impressive average rating of 4.7 stars based on over 1,400 Google reviews, the Fish Company encourages diners to explore a variety of dishes or indulge in their thoughtfully curated multi-course menu for a taste of the best offerings.
Don’t miss your chance to dine at the Fish Company—reserve your table today!
2. Kopar
Just steps from Reykjavik harbor lies Kopar, a restaurant celebrated for its cozy, stylish atmosphere and breathtaking views of Faxaflói Bay and Mount Esjan. With an impressive average rating of 4.6 stars from over 1,150 reviews, Kopar is not only a feast for the eyes but a culinary delight, boasting one of the best crab soups in all of Iceland.
The menu highlights include a rich lobster and crab risotto, alongside the ever-fresh catch of the day. To enhance your dining experience, an expertly crafted wine list and cocktails mixed by world-class mixologists await.
Guests can choose from a curated appetizer selection or embark on a culinary journey with a six-course adventure menu—easily adaptable to vegan preferences. However, the three-course fish adventure is a must-try for seafood lovers looking to savor the best of what’s on offer.
Save some room for dessert; the unique selection is worth it, with the date cake standing out as a particularly delightful choice.
Secure your reservation at Kopar today!
1. The Fish Market
If you’re in search of an exceptional culinary experience centered on fresh Icelandic seafood, look no further than the Fish Market. Helmed by the acclaimed chef Hrefna Sætran, this establishment offers a fascinating range of seafood dishes, often sourced directly from local farmers and fishermen.
The sushi selection features innovative combinations that highlight the freshness of Icelandic ingredients, while mains like miso black cod and lightly salted cod beckon diners. Be sure to explore their robust offerings from the robata grill as well!
For those short on time, consider opting for one of the tasting menus, which encompass a starter, sushi, main, and dessert—all designed for sharing, allowing you to sample the extensive selection available.
Housed in one of Reykjavik’s oldest buildings at Adalstraeti 12, the Fish Market boasts a stylish yet cozy atmosphere spread over three floors. The top floor is home to Uppi, a sophisticated wine bar and test kitchen, making it an ideal spot for post-meal relaxation or lively evenings out.
The Uppi wine bar offers one of the most comprehensive wine lists in Iceland, featuring several exclusive options. If you’re just in the mood for a drink with lighter fare, you can also reserve a table directly at Uppi.
If you decide to visit the Fish Market, you’re in for an extraordinary seafood experience. With an impressive average rating of 4.6 stars from over 1,150 reviews, make sure to include this dining destination in your Reykjavik itinerary.
Book your table at the Fish Market now!
Best Traditional Fish Restaurants in Reykjavik
While the restaurants on this list celebrate a variety of global influences, some are dedicated to the heart and soul of Icelandic cuisine. If you’re keen on experiencing the local food culture in a warm and welcoming setting, these traditional fish restaurants should be on your Reykjavik itinerary.
